Skip to main content

Sitter Insurance LLC Erie, PA Insurance Agency Auto, Home, Life and Business Insurance

Get a Quote

*indicates required field
Enter a zip code Enter a valid zip code

Agency Contact

About the Agency

Erie Insurance sells auto, home, life and business insurance through our network of independent agents in 12 states and the District of Columbia. The Gary R. Sitter Insurance Agency was established in 1978 by principal agent Gary Sitter and has represented Erie Insurance since then. The agency sells insurance for auto, home, business, life, annuities, ATV, motorcycle, RV, boat jet ski and snowmobile.

Personal Service

With the motto “Stick with the Man who Covers your Can,” Gary R. Sitter Insurance Agency provides fast, friendly service.

“We pride ourselves on the personal attention and the level of detail we give to each and every one of our policyholders both during and after the initial sale has been made,” says Gary. As the principal agent, Gary reviews all changes to policies for accuracy. Each year, the agency also completes a comprehensive review of all policies and sends out a letter of advice to keep customers informed of new ways to save.

“Prospects should consider doing business with our agency because we work hard to make sure their coverage is current and we continue to watch for areas where they can save as well as offer new coverage options that might be useful to them,” notes Gary. The agency takes the time to educate prospective customers so that they feel like they are empowered to make the best choices for their insurance needs.

Award-Winning Agency

Throughout the years, the agency has been awarded the Founders’ Award various times, as well as several life sales recognition awards.

Responsible and Knowledgeable Staff

A customer service representative with 20 years of experience, Liz, works alongside Gary.

“She is smart, friendly and enjoys helping people,” says Gary.

Stop by the Agency

The agency is located on West Ridge Road in Erie, Pennsylvania, between Asbury Road and Colonial Avenue on the south side of the street. Soon, there will be a 43,000-square foot medical facility owned by St. Vincent Hospital right next door to the agency.

Email Agency

*indicates required field

Enter a valid name
*I prefer to be contacted by

You must select a contact preference.

Enter a valid email
Enter a valid phone number
Please enter a brief description
1000 character limit

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.