Skip to main content

The Bagnall Shaw Agency LLC Lancaster, PA Insurance Agency Auto, Home, Life and Business Insurance

About the Agency

The Bagnall Shaw Agency is an independent insurance agency located in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. The agency proudly represents Erie Insurance, which sells auto, home, business and life insurance through a network of independent agents in 12 states and the District of Columbia. The agency offers many types of coverages, including commercial auto, personal auto, home, renters, builders risk, health, life, dental, disability, commercial liability, manufacturing/industrial, retail, business insurance, workers’ compensation, umbrellas, marine and much more.

Coverage Just for You

Principal agent, Aaron Alder, is a trained insurance professional, having served as agency principal with two of the most successful independent insurance agencies in the Atlanta, Georgia, area and as the director of operations for one of the fastest growing independent insurance holding companies in America, overseeing the management of 31 agencies in six states.

As a licensed insurance producer, Aaron’s goal is to provide his clients with adequate coverage while providing competitive pricing. “Imagine having a broker that ignores commissions and commits its focus to finding you the best insurance you can afford,” says Aaron. “That’s how we operate at Bagnall Shaw.”

The agency’s agents are highly skilled, experienced, bilingual advisors. Each aims to create long standing and trusting relationships with their customers in order to offer coverage options that meet their pricing and lifestyle needs.

Serving Others

Aaron values community service and helping others. He has traveled across the world, volunteering at hospitals in La Romana and has held multiple drives to aid victims of hurricanes and earthquakes.

Ask for Your Personal Quote

As one of the few independent insurance agencies in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, Bagnall Shaw Agency is proud to represent Erie Insurance in the downtown heart of Lancaster City. Call or stop in to learn more about your coverage options. The agency is located in a grey, three-story office building with white, oversized windows on the corner of West Orange and Charlotte streets.

Other languages spoken:

  • French
  • Spanish

Get a Quote

Enter a zip code Enter a valid zip code

Agency Contact

Email Agency

*indicates required field

Enter a valid name
*I prefer to be contacted by

You must select a contact preference.

Enter a valid email
Enter a valid phone number
Please enter a brief description
1000 character limit