Get a Quote
About Agency
The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency was established in 1919 in Shelby,Oh.The ERIE Agency offers Auto, Home, Business, Life, Medicare Supplement and Long Term Care insurance. Erie Insurance sells auto, home, business, and life insurance through our network of independent agents in 12 states and the District of Columbia.
Our Family Protecting the Future of Yours!
The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency principal agents are Tammy Armintrout and Justin Armintrout. The agency is involved in our community heavily. Taking pride and giving back is very important. We show this by being involved with such things as the Rotary Club of Shelby, the Community Improvement Corporation of Shelby, and the United Fund of Shelby.
Call us for a better insurance experience!
The agency is located in downtown Shelby near the corner of Main street and Gamble Street.
Follow Us
JUSTIN ARMINTROUT
- Enjoys helping others and putting customer needs first
- Community Centered
- Over 40 years combined Insurance experience