Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc.

Auto, Home, Life and Business Insurance

Grove City, OH Insurance Agency

Erie Insurance sells auto, home, life and business insurance through our network of independent agents in 12 states and the District of Columbia. Mitchell Insurance Agency was established in 1993 in Plain City, Ohio and has three Ohio and two Kentucky offices to serve you. In addition to Plain City, Ohio, you’ll find us in Grove City, Ohio; Lancaster, Ohio; Fort Mitchell, Kentucky; and Florence, Kentucky.

“Service Comes First”

Principal agent Robb Mitchell has over 25 years of insurance experience. Robb is very accomplished and is a proud recipient of the prestigious Erie Insurance F.W. Hirt Quality Agency Award.

Robb says: “Our number one goal is to provide excellent service for all of our clients’ insurance needs.” He is also very involved in his community and donates to organizations such as The Cure Tay-Sachs Foundation and Relay for Life, as well as local high-school scholarships.

Experienced Staff

He and his 21-person staff serve over 15,000 clients in the agency and take great pride in their exceptional customer service. The entire staff has combined insurance experience of more than 100 years.


In Grove City, Ohio, Mitchell Insurance Agency is located on Stringtown Road.

Please select an agent to continue.

Get A Quote
Enter a valid zip code Enter a zip code

Please select an agent to continue.