Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc.

When you insure with Mitchell Insurance Agency in Lancaster, Ohio, you gain access to over 20 years of insurance industry experience, knowledgeable and courteous staff and exemplary customer service.

Meeting Your Insurance Needs

Mitchell Insurance has been “Providing Service for All Your Insurance Needs” since 1993 when the agency was established in Hilliard, Ohio. The main office has since moved to Plain City, Ohio, but still provides unique insurance solutions to customers every day. 

Between the agency’s five locations, there are 26 employees ready to provide you with professional service and the best coverage for the best rate possible.

Giving Back to the Community

The agency actively supports multiple nonprofit organizations including The Cure Tay-Sachs Foundation and Relay for Life. For their extensive community involvement, they were awarded the Erie Insurance Giving Network Agency of the Year Award in 2010. They also received the Erie Insurance F. W. Hirt Quality Agency Award in 2014.

Visit the Agency

Mitchell Insurance Agency is located on East Sixth Avenue in Lancaster, Ohio. They also have four other locations:  Plain City and Grove City, Ohio, and Fort Mitchell and Florence, Kentucky.

Erie Insurance sells auto, home, life and business insurance through our network of independent agents in 12 states and the District of Columbia.